Skip to main content

Smalltalk Challenge: Post 10 - Conclusions

So here I am, more than 20 hours with Smalltalk and 10 blog posts about my experiences as required by the terms of my challenge. Josh said he chose Smalltalk for me because of the language's history of helping giving rise to object-oriented programming, which he thinks I hate. (For the record I don't hate OO; I hate the awkwardness and complexity its over-zealous application inflicts.) But I think secretly he was hoping it would endear me to Java in the same way as I was hoping OCaml would help him see past Java. Smalltalk gave me a newfound respect, not for OO, but for the language's innovations and lasting influence. If anything in relation to current-day OO practices, my experience confirmed how botched OO adoption has been given what it was intended to be. Regardless, while I don't think I'll be using Smalltalk in the foreseeable future, it was definitely fun to explore and gave me a lot of things to think about.

Smalltalk isn't a popular "mainstream" language like Java or PHP, but it was highly influential on many of them. It's a language that hasn't been afraid to try bold, new ideas. Other languages adopted its innovations; some did so successfully, others not so much. Will new innovations from Smalltalk and its community be just as influential in the future? I can't help but think that if Squeak has successfully abandoned the MVC architecture in favor of Morphic, maybe the days of MVC web frameworks such as Struts, Zend Framework, and Rails are numbered.

Message passing is a key concept in Smalltalk and provides the flexibility of duck typing. But late/dynamic binding prohibits many compiler-time optimizations that could otherwise be performed on statically-compiled code. Is there continued benefit to such an approach now that we're inundated with so many dynamic languages that have (or at least seem to emulate reasonably well) direct invocation, and thus better performance, such as Lua and JavaScript? Perhaps a greater benefit could be realized if message passing was handled asynchronously.

In Smalltalk, everything is an object. Even basic language constructs such as if-statements and while loops have been distilled down to objects and message passing. I respect Kay for intentionally taking an extreme position to force new ways of looking at things, though I believe the "everything is a" mindset can lead to awkward perceptions. The human mind is adept at categorizing things into different classifications exactly because not everything is the same. Ruby claims everything is an object too, which is misleading because it still has basic language constructs. I wonder where the sweet spot between abstraction and reality is, and in what ways can programming languages more accurately reflect how we view the world so we don't end up with with shimmed, over-architectured, spaghetti code.

Overall I found the core concepts of Smalltalk pretty easy to learn (since there are so few), and it was fun to write Smalltalk code and explore objects and Morphs in Squeak's environment. I encourage others who may not be familiar with Smalltalk to spend a little time with it as I did. I can't say it made me a better programmer, but in some sense it made me a better person because I now have a better understanding of history and a lot of things to think about.


Popular posts from this blog

Geolocation Search

Services that allow users to identify nearby points of interest continue to grow in popularity. I'm sure we're all familiar with social websites that let you search for the profiles of people near a postal code, or mobile applications that use geolocation to identify Thai restaurants within walking distance. It's surprisingly simple to implement such functionality, and in this post I will discuss how to do so.

The first step is to obtain the latitude and longitude coordinates of any locations you want to make searchable. In the restaurant scenario, you'd want the latitude and longitude of each eatery. In the social website scenario, you'd want to obtain a list of postal codes with their centroid latitude and longitude.

In general, postal code-based geolocation is a bad idea; their boundaries rarely form simple polygons, the area they cover vary in size, and are subject to change based on the whims of the postal service. But many times we find ourselves stuck on a c…

Composing Music with PHP

I’m not an expert on probability theory, artificial intelligence, and machine learning. And even my Music 201 class from years ago has been long forgotten. But if you’ll indulge me for the next 10 minutes, I think you’ll find that even just a little knowledge can yield impressive results if creatively woven together. I’d like to share with you how to teach PHP to compose music. Here’s an example: You’re looking at a melody generated by PHP. It’s not the most memorable, but it’s not unpleasant either. And surprisingly, the code to generate such sequences is rather brief. So what’s going on? The script calculates a probability map of melodic intervals and applies a Markov process to generate a new sequence. In friendlier terms, musical data is analyzed by a script to learn which intervals make up pleasing melodies. It then creates a new composition by selecting pitches based on the possibilities it’s observed. . Standing on ShouldersComposition doesn’t happen in a vacuum. Bach was f…

Creepy JavaScript Tracking

I recently began allergy shots so my new Monday morning routine includes me sitting in a doctor's office for 30 minutes (I must wait after receiving the shots and be checked by a nurse to make sure there was no reaction). With nothing else better to do while I waited last week, I started playing around with some JavaScript. This is what I came up with:
<html> <head> <title>Test</title> <script type="text/javascript"> window.onload = function () { var mX = 0,  mY = 0, sX = 0,  sY = 0, queue = [], interval = 200, recIntv = null, playIntv = null, b = document.body, de = document.documentElement, cursor = document.getElementById("cursor"), record = document.getElementById("record"), play = document.getElementById("play"); window.onmousemove = function (e) { e = e || window.event; if (e.pageX || e.pageY) { …