Skip to main content

Rent-free Thoughts

Some thoughts that have been living rent-free recently in my head about AI...

We should be more precise when we talk about it. We’ve had "AI" for decades. Google Translate, Alexa and Siri, computer vision in video games, OCR in mail sorting, protein folding models all fall under artificial intelligence, but there’s no mass panic over these. The current progress is in generative AI, and that's where most of the public concern is. I’m guilty of the shorthand myself, saying "AI" when I mean "generative AI".

People are afraid of generative AI, but the real problem is concentrated power and corporate greed. Someone wanting to sow disinformation could do so without generative AI models, and deep-pocket organizations of state could finance extreme actors if they wanted to. The tools evolved, but the risks aren’t new. The bigger problem that few are talking about is corporations who are aligning the technology for their own goals; they increasingly dictatate what we can use and how we can use it. Railroads were good for America, but robber barons were not. The new American technological libertarianism can lead to innovation and profits, but how do we ensure profit doesn’t eclipse regard for human worth or societial integrity? I don’t have an answer.

AI coding tools could lock in bad practices. Models are trained on massive amounts of code, much of which is dated. But best practices evolve. What was considered good PHP or JavaScript ten years ago is not what we consider best practices today. And retraining models is expensive. If models mostly generate code from old samples, and languages for new projects are picked based on AI support rather than if they're the best fit for the problem domain, the industry is going to end up stagnating with mediocre JavaScript and Python code.

Generative AI is useful, but the truly valuable applications have yet to arrive. The real winners won’t be those who use AI tooling to solve niche problems, like writing code, generate marketing plans, or “talking” to PDFs. And cramming chatbot technology into existing apps and websites isn’t what the market really wants. The real winners will be those who find a genuinely useful application for it. The first example of an interesting AI driven application I’ve seen is Google’s NotebookLM as a study aid. There are probably a lot of behind-the-scenes wins available too, for example reliable data structuring and other ETL tasks.

A few extra stand-alone assertions:

  • No one cares about prompting, they just want things to work.
  • I have no issue with generated content. I do have issue with slop. Unfortunately, there’s a lot of lazy slop right now.
  • I don’t trust Sam Altman, Mark Zuckerberg, or Elon Musk’s vision for humanity’s future. Unless they’re offering me a job.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

What's Wrong with OOP

Proponents of Object Oriented Programming feel the paradigm yields code that is better organized, easier to understand and maintain, and reusable. They view procedural programming code as unwieldy spaghetti and embrace OO-centric design patterns as the "right way" to do things. They argue objects are easier to grasp because they model how we view the world. If the popularity of languages like Java and C# is any indication, they may be right. But after almost 20 years of OOP in the mainstream, there's still a large portion of programmers who resist it. If objects truly model the way people think of things in the real world, then why do people have a hard time understanding and working in OOP? I suspect the problem might be the focus on objects instead of actions. If I may quote from Steve Yegge's Execution in the Kingdom of Nouns : Verbs in Javaland are responsible for all the work, but as they are held in contempt by all, no Verb is ever permitted to wander about ...

Does Esperanto-USA have a Transparency Problem?

I’ve been an active member of Esperanto-USA for many years, even serving on its board of directors. I wanted to help build a strong, healthy national organization that effectively promotes Esperanto in the United States. But when I stepped down from the board, that desire didn’t end. I continued to bring problems to the attention of the organization, ranging from member rights to strategy to proper governance. I’ve decided to be public about this latest issue because of its seriousness and because of how the board has been secretive about it. The membership deserves to know what is done in their name. What Happened In November 2025, the board of Esperanto-USA sent a formal letter to Esperanto-Ligo en Israelo (ELI) with a copy to UEA, concerning an article published in ELI’s bulletin. The article, written by Eduardo Topol, contained inflammatory political content. And although I agree that the article was extremely offensive, the board’s decision to inj...

Learning Prolog

I'm not quite sure exactly I was searching for, but somehow I serendipitously stumbled upon the site learnprolognow.org a few months ago. It's the home for an introductory Prolog programming course. Logic programming offers an interesting way to think about your problems; I've been doing so much procedural and object-oriented programming in the past decade that it really took effort to think at a higher level! I found the most interesting features to be definite clause grammars (DCG), and unification. Difference lists are very powerful and Prolog's DCG syntax makes it easy to work with them. Specifying a grammar such as: s(s(NP,VP)) --> np(NP,X,Y,subject), vp(VP,X,Y). np(np(DET,NBAR,PP),X,Y,_) --> det(DET,X), nbar(NBAR,X,Y), pp(PP). np(np(DET,NBAR),X,Y,_) --> det(DET,X), nbar(NBAR,X,Y). np(np(PRO),X,Y,Z) --> pro(PRO,X,Y,Z). vp(vp(V),X,Y) --> v(V,X,Y). vp(vp(V,NP),X,Y) --> v(V,X,Y), np(NP,_,_,object). nbar(nbar(JP),X,3) --> jp(JP,X). pp(pp(PREP,N...